Well I installed a free StartCom SSL certificate. Of course IE doesn't have StartCom as a trusted certicate authority, but I don't cater to IE users. So if you're trying to log in with IE, you'll just have to deal with the warning.
Firefox works. Safari for Mac is suppose to work, but Safari for Windows doesn't currently work. Oh well. I was thinking about paying for a cheap SSL cert, but why in the world would I pay for a cert when I have 5 viewers on my page? At least Firefox users can feel safer. 🙂